UFC on Versus 4
Collapse
X
-
-
I am not taking sides in this debate, I admit I know nothing about TRT... except that it is for pussies.
But I think Luke's comparison is sound. Some people have a genetic advantage to have better cardio or bigger muscles. Even though I may be able to improve upon on my small muscles and weak cardio through effort, I can never fix it to level of some guys that are just genetically advantaged in those areas. So Luke is saying that having low testosterone is the same as having a genetic weakness lung capacity or muscle building capacity. You just play the hand you were dealt, you don't play chemist with it and then whine about it when it throws everything off because you could not tinker it to the exact level needed.2012: +19.33
2012 Parlay project: +16.5uComment
-
You win ........I don't honestly care
Maybe had you said "what do you mean?" instead of "dumb comment" I would have come off a little less harsh2015 MMA BETTING CHAMP

Comment
-
I am not taking sides in this debate, I admit I know nothing about TRT... except that it is for pussies.
But I think Luke's comparison is sound. Some people have a genetic advantage to have better cardio or bigger muscles. Even though I may be able to improve upon on my small muscles and weak cardio through effort, I can never fix it to level of some guys that are just genetically advantaged in those areas. So Luke is saying that having low testosterone is the same as having a genetic weakness lung capacity or muscle building capacity. You just play the hand you were dealt, you don't play chemist with it and then whine about it when it throws everything off because you could not tinker it to the exact level needed.
Yeah, but if you want to take that argument to its logical conclusion, then you could say that a fighter shouldn't take antibiotics on fight night if they're sick. Because at that moment their body's natural state is to be sick. So altering that is cheating.
Also, where do you draw the line? A fighter can't supplement with test, so maybe they shouldn't try to increase their size by eating more, taking creatine, or increasing their protein intake? Maybe they just shouldn't be able to lift weights or run?
Everything fighters do is to increase the way they are able to perform, whether it's a form of exercise, or it's a substance like creatine or protein, or it's sleeping in a hyperbaric chamber.
It seems that a lot of people, like yourself, get hung up when it comes to a substance that is synthetic. If it comes from the earth, it's not cheating to use it. If it was created in a lab--even if it's simply a synthetic version of something your body already produces--then it's cheating.
Why is that?I heart cockComment
-
Well like I said, I don't know anything about it... I just don't believe that all these fighters have naturally low testosterone levels and require TRT. At one point I think all of the original Team Quest guys (Hendo, Couture, Lindland) were on TRT. That would have to be one hell of a hypogonadal coincidence.
I was just saying, from a logic standpoint, it makes some sense...
Anyway, When Sonnen and Marquart fought, I wonder how much testosterone was in the cage.
I told you guys about the guy at my gym that started TRT, and then suddenly was awesome. Well, he had all sorts of problems like 2 months later and he would just crash and feel like he was having a hear attack. And then he quit. He had 10 years in, went on TRT, got in magic shape, then it all came crashing down.2012: +19.33
2012 Parlay project: +16.5uComment
-
BOL
@nathanmarquardt you are a cheater, not once but frequently. Stop cheating, come to bellator and I will crush you. @bjornrebney
-Ben AskrenComment
-
I have heard(and like Scientist I don't know much about this either way so bare with Me) that having low Testosterone levels can drastically decrease energy for even normal everyday things. If thats the case why wouldn't someone get on some kind of treatment to even be able to work as hard as a person with normal levels? I agree that the whole concept is subjective and that different doctors may read the test results differently and alot like medical marijuana it could become out of hand. But it's not like having bad cardio where you will fade because you don't work hard enough at it, you'll start to fade because you CAN'T work hard enough.
I remember reading something about wrestlers commonly suffering from low testosterone levels because of the constant weight fluctuation from cutting weight and putting it back on rapidly. If that is true then I could see plenty of fighters having a need for TRT but at the same time again, how many of them are milking it?Last edited by Ludo; 06-28-2011, 02:24 PM.2013: +8.24u(increased unit size on 5/19)
Favorites: 20-6 + 6.13u
Underdogs: 10-19 -2.51u
Ludo's Locks Parlay Project: +1.4u
2012: +20.311uComment
-
Like I said, I am not agreeing or disagreeing, just pointing out that the argument has some merit.Yeah, but if you want to take that argument to its logical conclusion, then you could say that a fighter shouldn't take antibiotics on fight night if they're sick. Because at that moment their body's natural state is to be sick. So altering that is cheating.
Also, where do you draw the line? A fighter can't supplement with test, so maybe they shouldn't try to increase their size by eating more, taking creatine, or increasing their protein intake? Maybe they just shouldn't be able to lift weights or run?
Everything fighters do is to increase the way they are able to perform, whether it's a form of exercise, or it's a substance like creatine or protein, or it's sleeping in a hyperbaric chamber.
It seems that a lot of people, like yourself, get hung up when it comes to a substance that is synthetic. If it comes from the earth, it's not cheating to use it. If it was created in a lab--even if it's simply a synthetic version of something your body already produces--then it's cheating.
Why is that?
But to answer your question, I would draw a distinction between eating and working out and drug therapy because eating and exercising are things we have to do to live (or function at least). Those are the natural requirements of living as a human, and to do it more or better that is what sport is about. We do not have to inject synthetic testosterone into our bodies. Or there may be some people that do, but not Marquart or Sonnen. As for creatine vs. TRT, I think you make a valid point, I don't know much about it though (creatine). One is just more effective that the other.
That is just my opinion, my position, it is not a fact, but that is the distinction that I draw. I have never taken creatine either FWIW.2012: +19.33
2012 Parlay project: +16.5uComment
-
Hell yes. I love Askren.BOL
@nathanmarquardt you are a cheater, not once but frequently. Stop cheating, come to bellator and I will crush you. @bjornrebney
-Ben Askren2012: +19.33
2012 Parlay project: +16.5uComment

Comment